Bone loss accelerates
suddenly in menopausal women because the drop in estrogen levels causes
an increase in the resorption (teardown) of existing bone.
But resorption is only half of the story. Age-related bone loss is
also caused by a decrease in the formation of new bone
tissue.
Existing drugs for treating osteoporosis, as well as calcium and vitamin
D supplements, work by reducing bone resorption. But they do not support
the formation of new bone. These drugs and nutrients increase the
mineralization of bone, but they do not
help the body to build new bone tissue. And in fact, within weeks of
starting use of antiresorptive drugs like Fosamax,®
the body’s formation of new bone actually decreases. The
resulting bone is less prone to fracture, but is not the same as
youthful, healthy bone.
Strontium is a mineral found along with calcium in most foods.
Research has long suggested that it may be an essential nutrient
required for the normal development, structure, function, and health of
the skeletal system. Clinical trials going back into the 1940s have
supported this conclusion, but recent studies have provided evidence
that it can offer unique nutritional support against loss of bone
structure and function.
Animal studies have shown that Strontium supplements both decrease
bone resorption, and increase the formation of new bone tissue.
• In animal models, Strontium (in various forms, such as
chloride, carbonate, gluconate, and lactate) causes “baby”
osteoblasts (bone-building cells) to multiply more quickly.
• Bone tissue cultures which are exposed to Strontium synthesize
more bone matrix and new bone collagen. The same amount of
calcium has no effect on these parameters.
• In bone tissue culture, Strontium reduces bone resorption at
concentrations at which calcium has no effect, prevents the resorption
caused by excessive parathyroid hormone, and slows the rate at
which immature osteoclasts develop.
• Strontium-supplemented diets boost bone strength in
experimental animals without a negative impact on bone quality,
even at extremely high doses.
Human clinical trials also support Strontium’s ability to both
support new bone formation and prevent excessive resorption.
• The results of early clinical trials using Strontium (lactate)
led researchers to speculate that Strontium increased osteoblast
activity.
• Bone biopsies from a small human pilot trial revealed an astounding
172.4% increase in new bone formation after six months of Strontium
(gluconate) supplementation.
• The bone-building activity of osteoblasts can be measured using
bone-specific alkaline phosphatase, while crosslinked N-telopeptide
(NTx) and C-telopeptide (CTx) mark the degradation of bone
collagen by ravaging osteoclasts.
Unlike the range of side-effects that accompany antiresorptive drugs,
no clinical side-effects have ever been reported that could be clearly
attributed to Strontium.
Calcium and Strontium: the Dynamic Tension
Calcium and Strontium can both play key roles in the health of
your bones – if you use them properly. On the one hand, animal
studies suggest that Strontium is not effective, and may even be
counterproductive, if your calcium intake is not adequate.
Current “official” recommendations suggest an intake of 1000 milligrams
of calcium for younger adults, and 1200 milligrams for people over the
age of 50. Some evidence suggests that a still higher intake
(1300-1600 milligrams) of calcium is more effective for lowering
fracture risk in the elderly. But remember that these numbers are
your total calcium need. The more calcium you get in your diet,
the less you need from supplements.
At the same time, however, it’s important not to take your Strontium
supplement at the same time as your calcium supplements. This
is because calcium and Strontium use the same pathways for
absorption in the intestinal tract, so that swallowing a calcium
supplement along with your Strontium can dramatically reduce
absorption. So obviously, putting Strontium and calcium in the
same pill is a recipe for bone health disaster, in which you don’t
get the benefits of either nutrient!
The best protocol – and the one used in the most recent clinical trials
– is to take your Strontium either three hours after your last
meal of the day, or one hour before breakfast in the morning, or both.
Because studies suggest that one last dose of calcium just before
retiring can help prevent excessive resorption of bone overnight, it may
be best to take all of your Strontium before breakfast, leaving
you free to take a calcium supplement just before you go to bed.
Like the Strontium carbonate crystals (strontianite) from
which it was first isolated, Strontium’s role in bone health has
long been hidden in obscurity. But its strength has allowed it to
endure, waiting for the day that it could emerge and reveal its power.
References
1 Sips, AJAM et-al. Intestinal absorption of strontium chloride in
healthy volunteers: pharmacokinetics and reproducibility.Br. J Clin
Pharmacol. 1996;41:543-549
2 Sips, AJAM.Absoption kinetics of strontium and calcium in human and
experimental animal. Ph.D Thesis. University of Amsterdam. 1994
3 Skoryna, SC. Effects of oral supplementation with stable strontium.
Can Med J. 1981;125:703-712
4 ATSDR.Toxicological profile for strontium. Atlanta,GA: Agency for
toxic substances and disease registry US Dept of Health and Human
Services. Public Health Services.2001
5 Leeuwenkamp,OR et-al. Human pharmacokinetics of orally administered
strontium. Calcif. Tissue Int. 1990;47:136-140
6 Marie,PJ et-al. Effect of low doses of stable strontium on bone
metabolism in rats. Mineral Electrolyte Metab. 1985;11:5-13
7 Shorr, E and Carter, AC. The value of strontium as an adjuvant to
calcium in the mineralization of the skeleton in osteoporosis in man.
Conference on Metabolic Interactions. Eds. EC Reifenstein Jr.,NY.NY.Pub
J Macy Foundation 1950 pp144-154.
8 McCaslin FE and Janes, HM. The effect of strontium lactate in the
treatment of osteoporosis. Proc. Mayo Clinic. 1959;34:329-334
9 Skoryna,SC and Fuskova, M. In: Skoryna, SC ed. Handbook of stable
strontium.NY;Plenum:1985.p593-617
10 Comar,CL , Wasserman, RH and Nold, NM. Strontium-Calcium
discrimination factors in the rat. Proc. Sco. Exp. Biol.
Med.1950;92:859-863
11 Della Rossa et-al. Absorption and retention of ingested strontium and
calcium in beagles as a function of age. Nature.1965;205:197-198
12 Skoryna, SC.Metabolic aspects of the pharmacologic uses of trace
elements in human subjects with specific references to stable strontium.
Trace Subst. Enviorn Health.1984;18:3-23
13 Dahl, SG et-al. Incorporation and distribution of strontium in bone.
Bone.2001;28:446-453
14 Storey,E. Strontium “rickets” bone calcium and strontium changes.
Austral.Ann. Med. 1961;10:213-222
15 Matsumoto, A. Effect of strontium chloride on bone resorption induced
by prostaglandin E2 in cultured bone. Arch. Toxicol. 1988;62:240-241
16 Marie,PJ et-al. Mechanisms of action and therapeutic potential of
strontium in bone. Calcif. Tissue Int.2001;69:121-129.